Tuesday, June 19, 2018

Can You Be Certain?


I was doing my usual channel surfing recently.  It is a known fact that men are not as concerned with ‘what’s on TV’ as much as we are interested in, ‘what else is on TV’.  I think it comes from our heritage of being adventure seeking discoverers as ‘hunter/gatherers’.  Women are usually less prone to channel surf as their heritage leans more to ‘nesting’.  But I digress.  Back to the point, I was channel surfing and ran across a program on the recent suicide of celebrity chef, Anthony Bourdain.  They were playing a montage of clips and quotes from his programs about his life and travels.  He spoke of a tattoo he had on his arm that said, “I am certain of nothing”.  This tattoo described his continuing search for meaning and purpose.  He spoke of having respect for religion but he leaned toward atheism. 

The quote “I am certain of nothing” is a partial quote from Romanticist poet, John Keats.  In a letter to his friend, Benjamin Bailey, Keats wrote “I am certain of nothing but the holiness of the heart's affections and the truth of the imagination”. The letter was written speculating on religion and imagination.  It is believed that since his friend Benjamin was studying theology, they may have had discussions regarding theological philosophies during Keats stay at Oxford that influenced this letter. In this quotation, Keats is telling his friend that he is confident in the sacredness of things that the heart finds pleasure in and the reality that can be invoked by creativity.

All through history people have sought to find meaning, purpose and joy in life.  Keats found meaning in imagination and creativity.  Anthony Bourdain seemed to have a great gig going; in fact I recently told my wife that although I am enjoying retirement I would not mind his job; traveling to exotic destinations, meeting interesting people and eating all kinds of food…and getting paid for it!  However, there was emptiness in his quest that was revealed not only in his tattoo but in his final act.  He had riches, fame and was doing what he seemed to love.  He was filming another episode of his show on travel and gourmet food in the city best known for such but he decided to end his own life by hanging himself with his bathrobe belt in a motel room in Paris. 

In my days of being employed as a minister part of my work was research.  I once ran across an article, by an anonymousAre  non-believer asking ‘What is the Point of Life?’  The writer argued, “that the only reality we have is the present, the more life seems somewhat pointless – particularly if there is nothing after this existence and can't be sure that there is something more. And let's be honest, we can't be certain. No matter how strong our faith in a particular religion or philosophy, we can only ‘believe' if we don't have the evidence to truly ‘know'.  Saying, “I believe”, is never an adequate substitute for being able to say, “I know”, and faith is largely centered around belief because it relies on second, third, fourth (and so on) accounts of things that may or may not be true.”

His conclusion with his supposition that we can’t be certain of anything but the present was this; “The point is to live with what you know to be real. But the fact is, we don't know what's around the corner, what happens when we die or even the true extent of the control we have over our lives. What we do know is that we have an awareness of being here now. Stop for a moment and look around. That's an awareness looking through those eyes; a soul, a physical being, a personality, a beautiful individual. Don't spend your life believing, because the happiness is in the knowing. There's nothing to hope for in the future but everything to embrace right this second. This is the point. You are the point, along with every other living organism that surrounds your existence in this moment. The tiniest, seemingly insignificant insect you see on the floor is a fundamental part of the point, because you know it exists in the here and now.  When we start living with what is real, the point of life falls into place. It has context, substance and meaning. Live in the present moment, stick with what you know to be real and the meaning of life will become your individual experience of joy. Any thoughts of what might be will become just that, thoughts, rather than self-prophesying “beliefs” that amount to non-reality living."

While I obviously don’t agree with everything that writer said, I do agree that living a life enjoying the reality of the moment is not such a bad way to live.  In fact, Jesus tells us not to worry about tomorrow.  Contrary to the writer, who says that ‘we don’t know what is around the corner’, Jesus is tells us that we can trust Him for ‘what is around the corner’ and that is why we can enjoy the reality of the day and not worry about tomorrow.  I also agree that things we, as believers, hold dear in our faith cannot be proven as reality in a laboratory however, the things that can be proven in a laboratory or the reality of the ‘here and now’ are not the embodiment of ultimate truth.  While Anthony Bourdain tattooed, “I am certain of nothing” on his arm Jesus spoke often of the importance and power of belief and faith.  Hebrews 11:1 says this about faith, “Now faith is being sure of what we hope for and certain of what we do not see.”  Believers have assurance and certainty that non-believers can never know. 

So, before I get too long-winded in making my point (which my wife will say that I already have done), I guess what I am trying to convey is that the pursuit of joy and meaning in life comes down to three choices.  I loved multiple choice test questions because there was always a chance that I might get the right answer with a wild guess even when I was clueless.  This question of finding meaning and purpose in the way we live is far too important to make a wild guess.  Nevertheless, we can choose, as the practicing non-believer would choose, to live a life of total uncertainty and unbelief in anything which usually leads to despair (notice I am not using the word atheist as some non-believers are actually agnostics (which means they are not sure whether God is real or not and are just uncertain…as the tattoo on Anthony Bourdain’s arm suggests).
The second choice is stated in the article I shared where the non-believer chose to live a life of believing only in the reality of the moment.  This also can lead to a negative outcome as one has no real regard of the future since the only reality they can know is now.  This belief usually leads to Epicureanism which Paul referred to in Corinthians 15:32, saying what is the point if there is no resurrection we might as well follow the philosophy; “let us eat and drink, for tomorrow we will be dead.”  

Thank goodness there is a third choice.  One does not have to live a life of hopeless despair and unbelief or a life of Epicureanism pleasure seeking.  The third choice is to live a life of faith in Christ.  Jesus speaks of living in the moment because we are trusting tomorrow to Him.  Jesus speaks of living a full and abundant life as we make the most of today loving our fellowman as we love ourselves and loving God with all our heart soul and mind.  Jesus speaks of eternal hope and rewards when we live a life of faith. 

So, while some may struggle with living a life of meaningless uncertainty or a life of empty pleasure seeking...I may be a product of the Mississippi public school system but I think the smart choice is number three; choosing to live each day as a life of faith in Christ.